Temple Emanu-El of Atlanta

Member Supported-Future Driven

  • My EmanuEl
  • Kesher Quick
  • TE Atlanta Calendar
  • TE Israel Trip Summer 2022
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Home
  • About Us
    • We are…
    • Meet Our Clergy
      • Senior Rabbi Spike Anderson
      • Cantor Lauren Adesnik
      • Rabbi Rachael Klein Miller
      • Rabbi Max Miller
      • Rabbi Emeritus Scott Colbert
      • Rabbi Emeritus Stanley Davids
    • Meet Our Staff
    • Meet Our Leadership
    • Temple Emanu-El Calendar
    • Temple Emanu-El In the News
    • Contact Us
  • Belong
    • Membership
    • My Emanu-El
    • Inclusion Awareness
    • Friendship/Chavurah Program
    • Interfaith Families
    • Young Adults: Next Dor
    • Sisterhood
    • Brotherhood
  • Pray
    • Shabbat Services
    • High Holy Days 5782
    • Jewish Holidays
    • Tot Shabbat
    • Rabbis’ Sermons
  • Learn
    • Diamond Family Religious School
      • About Our School
      • Meet Our Teachers
      • Our Curriculum
      • Diamond Family Religious School Pre-Kindergarten Program
      • Registration and Forms
      • Hebrew Skills
      • School Calendar
      • School Blog
    • Life Long Learning 5782
    • The MJCCA Schiff Preschool
    • Your Jewish Journey
    • Living History
  • Celebrate
    • Bar/Bat Mitzvah
    • Adult B’nei Mitzvah
    • Baby Naming & Brit Milah
    • Weddings
    • Becoming Jewish
    • Confirmation
    • Space Rental
    • L’Dor V’Dor Spring Forward Fundraiser 2022
  • Tikkun Olam
    • Social Justice
      • Hunger
      • Interfaith and Race Relations
      • Women and Children
      • Immigration Issues
      • Education
      • Environment
    • TEams and Committees
    • Israel and Peoplehood
  • Empower Youth
    • Youth Groups
      • TEFTY Youth Group
    • College Outreach
    • Jewish Summer Camps and Youth Resources
    • Youth Connectors
    • Schiffer Teen Israel Trip
    • Scholarships
  • Support
    • Donate
    • Endowment Fund
    • Life and Legacy
  • Remember
    • Funerals & Memorials
    • Grief
    • Yizkor Service
    • Talking to Kids About Death
    • Holocaust Remembrance
  • Live Stream

Free Speech Denied in the Torah

June 24, 2021 by Rabbi Max Miller 1 Comment

In the Torah portion for this week, King Balak of the Amonites hires Balaam, a mercenary sorcerer, to curse the Israelites. For reasons we don’t learn from the Torah text, Balaam is able to summon God’s power, so if left unchecked, Balaam could do some real damage to the Israelites. Reluctently, Balaam agrees to King Balak’s request to curse the Israelites, but whenever Balaam summons the power of the curse, God changes the words from a curse to a blessing. In fact, this is the spot in the Torah where we read blessing, “mah tovu ohalecha ya’akov, mishk’notecha yisrael,” How lovely are your tents O’ Jacob, your dwelling places O’ Israel. God won’t allow Balaam to use any curse words, and in fact turns Balaam’s curses into blessings. God is regulating free speech! 

The study of Torah can be simply for personal spiritual fulfillment, but I believe a more powerful approach is to study Torah and use it as a lens through which we evaluate our actions and our beliefs. Whenever we have the opportunity to connect or relate what takes place in the Torah, a document over 2000 years old, to current events, we would be remised by ignoring the chance. 

The irony between parashat Balak and Balaam’s curse words, and the recent 8-1 decision in the Supreme Court case MAHANOY AREA SCHOOL DISTRICT v. BRANDI LEVY is too overt to ignore. Whereas the Supreme Court determined that Brandi Levy’s curse words were allowed off-campus, God determined that Balaam’s curse words were not. Obviously, there are a few factors that differentiate high schooler Brandi Levy and biblical sorcerer Balaam: one is venting their anger and one is a questionably evil magician looking to harm the Israelites. Yet, we ought to inspect these two cases together. Though we all understand that Ms. Levy was not actually cursing anyone when she spoke those words, we still call profanity by another name: “curse words.”  

As we read two sets of curses spoken millennia apart, we would do well to differentiate between the kind of free speech that we defend today, and the lack of free speech we read in this story from the Torah. While Ms. Levy’s words were certainly spoken with anger, they were not intended nor likely to do physical harm; however, Balaam’s words would have been devastating if God had not intervened. The Israelites might have suffered a colossal defeat and scores might have died. This is where Justice Stephen Breyer, writing for the majority, assert a very Jewish distinction. Namely, that there could be cases where speech which does lead to classroom disruption, violence, bullying, or harassment is not protected on or off-campus. Justice Breyer is drawing a distinction between words like Balaam’s and words like Brandi’s: while they are both spoken acts, the overall intention and affect is very different.     

What we learn repeatedly in the Torah is that words have just as much potential power as any physical action; God creates the world through spoken world; Moses draws water from a rock by speaking to it; and Balaam attempts to maim the Israelites through his curses. If Moses were a judge on this Supreme Court we cannot say how he would have decided Ms. Levy’s case; however, that should not stop us from using the lens of Torah to help us make sense of the world around us.  

AJT-Rabbi Max's Holiday Message

Filed Under: kesherquick

Comments

  1. Jessie Herman says

    June 27, 2021 at 6:13 pm

    I am not familiar at all with MAHANOY AREA SCHOOL DISTRICT v. BRANDI LEVY. So was Brandi at some off-campus school event when she cursed? What was the ruling? Was Brandi found that she had the right to “swear and use profaninty because she wasn’t bad mouthing anyone? Or was this simply freedom of speach?

    Thanks,
    Jessie

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Visit Us

Temple Emanu-El
1580 Spalding Drive
Atlanta, GA 30350

Union for Reform Judasim

Union for Reform Judasim

Contact Us

(770) 395-1340

Diamond Family Religious School

Diamond Family Religious School

MJCCA The Schiff School

MJCCA The Schiff School
  • TE Israel Trip Summer 2022
  • My Emanu-El
  • Kesher Quick
  • Calendar
Copyright © 2022 Temple Emanu-El
Scroll Up