Temple Emanu-El of Atlanta

Member Supported-Future Driven

  • My EmanuEl
  • TE Atlanta Calendar
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Meet Our Clergy
      • Senior Rabbi Spike Anderson
      • Rabbi Rachael Klein Miller
      • Rabbi Max Miller
      • Rabbi Emeritus Scott Colbert
      • Rabbi Emeritus Stanley Davids z’l
    • Meet Our Staff
    • Meet Our Leadership
    • Temple Emanu-El Calendar
    • Temple Emanu-El In the News
    • Contact Us
  • Belong
    • Membership
    • My Emanu-El
    • Teams and Committees
    • Inclusion Awareness
    • Friendship/Chavurah Program
    • Interfaith Families
    • NextDor 20s and 30s
    • Yalla-Youth And Loving Adults
    • Sisterhood
    • Brotherhood
  • Pray
    • Shabbat Services
    • High Holy Days 5787
    • Jewish Holidays
    • Tot Shabbat & Kid-ish
    • Rabbis’ Sermons
    • Live Stream
    • Remember
      • Funerals & Memorials
      • Grief
      • Yizkor Service
      • Talking to Kids About Death
      • Holocaust Remembrance
  • Learn
    • Diamond Family Religious School
      • About Our School
      • Meet Our Teachers
      • Our Curriculum
      • Diamond Family Religious School Pre-Kindergarten Program
      • Registration and Forms
      • Hebrew Skills
      • School Calendar
      • School Blog
    • Life Long Learning 5787
    • The MJCCA Schiff Preschool
    • Your Jewish Journey
    • Living History
  • Celebrate
    • Bar/Bat Mitzvah
    • Adult B’nei Mitzvah
    • Baby Naming & Brit Milah
    • Weddings
    • Becoming Jewish
    • Confirmation
    • Space Rental
    • Spring Forward-A Night In Tel Aviv 2023
  • Tikkun Olam
    • Tikkun Olam Initiatives
      • Antisemitism
      • Hunger
      • Multifaith Connections and Interracial Alliance Group
      • Women and Children
      • Immigration Issues
      • Education
      • Environment
  • Israel and Peoplehood
    • Standing With Israel
    • Antisemitism
    • Travel to Israel
  • Empower Youth
    • Youth Groups
    • College Outreach
    • Jewish Summer Camps and Youth Resources
    • Youth Connectors
    • Scholarships
  • Support
    • Donate
    • Endowment Fund
    • Life and Legacy

Relative Justice

October 7, 2021 by Rabbi Max Miller

The other morning, I was listening to National Public Radio, when I heard a story about Charles and Willa Bruce. The Bruce Family used to own a beachside resort in the town of Manhattan Beach, California that was a haven for black Californians who faced endless restrictions under the racist Jim Crow laws of the time. After enduring countless acts of terrorism and racism at the hands of the KKK, in 1924, the California state government exercised eminent domain over the property at the behest of the white neighbors, stripping the Bruce’s of their land, their business, and their fortune—a grievous act of injustice. A week ago, nearly a century after the state took the property, the California state legislature issued an apology and returned the property to the descendants of Charles and Willa Bruce. Certainly, that was the right thing to do even though it took far too long.

This story brought me to a topic of our Torah portion this week, Noach, that we often study. Noach is considered righteous, blameless in his generation, someone who walked with God. At the same time, we read nothing about what he did to earn such accolades. Add to that, we cannot decide how to read “in his generation.” We can’t decide whether Noach’s righteousness is relative to the wickedness of his contemporaries, or if Noach was righteous, blameless, and one who would have walked with God in each and every generation.

Rabbinic commentaries add that Noach was only righteous in his generation, and not others, because he did not extend his efforts to bring greater justice to the world. He focused only on his family and himself. When God told Noach of God’s plans to destroy the world, Noach didn’t object or fight to save anyone, unlike his descendant Abraham who will argue with God to the very end to save even ten people from the cities of Sodom and Gomorrah. By comparing Noach and Abraham, we learn the true measure of justice and righteousness. Living a just life for yourself is noteworthy and admirable. However, greater than that is when we extend care and compassion for others, regardless of our relationship to them or their own level of goodness or lack thereof.

The story of the Bruce family is just one in a sea of those who suffered from injustice at the hands of figurative citizens of Sodom and Gomorrah. Though we know there were Abrahams in that time, there were not enough. Similarly, today, God’s creatures continue to suffer at the hands of evil and injustice, and though we endeavor to be like Abraham, we constantly work to extend righteousness and goodness beyond our borders. We must take those who would sit contently and safely as Noach did and disturb their peaceful dwelling so that they become like Abraham.

At the end of Noach’s story, we read about a guilt-laden man ashamed of his actions and inactions. Noach turns to alcohol and attempts to drown his shame. Whereas, Abraham, though tormented by injustice in the world, ceaselessly works to take his world from where it is to where it needs to be. May we be a community of Abrahams, living lives of justice, seeking peace in our homes, our streets, and in our world -- or us, all of Israel, and all of God’s creations.

AJT-Rabbi Max's Holiday Message

Filed Under: kesherquick

Visit Us

Temple Emanu-El
1580 Spalding Drive
Atlanta, GA 30350

Union for Reform Judasim

Union for Reform Judasim

Contact Us

(770) 395-1340

Diamond Family Religious School

Diamond Family Religious School

MJCCA The Schiff School

MJCCA The Schiff School
  • My Emanu-El
  • Kesher Quick
  • Calendar
Copyright © 2026 Temple Emanu-El
Scroll Up